Accidental Landlords on the Rise: What It Means for Utah’s Rental Market

Key Takeaways

• Rising mortgage rates and hesitant buyers are pushing more homeowners into becoming “accidental landlords.”
• Delistings have jumped by over 40 percent, signaling sellers are renting rather than cutting prices.
• Utah renters may benefit from more single-family rental options, though rent growth is expected to slow to 1–2 percent.
• Accidental landlords face challenges like tenant screening, maintenance, compliance, and rent collection.
• Partnering with a property management company can simplify the transition and maximize returns.

The housing market in 2025 is full of surprises. With high mortgage rates, hesitant buyers, and an increasing number of homes sitting unsold, many homeowners are finding themselves in an unexpected role: becoming “accidental landlords.” These are property owners who initially wanted to sell but, unable to secure the right buyer, choose instead to rent out their homes.

This shift is growing quickly. Delistings have risen significantly, with some reports showing increases of more than 40 percent compared to last year. Instead of lowering their prices, many sellers are holding onto their equity and renting their properties, creating a noticeable ripple effect in the rental market.

Why Homeowners Are Turning to Rentals

Three main factors are fueling this rise:

1. High mortgage rates – keeping potential buyers on the sidelines.
2. Rising inventory – homes are sitting longer without offers.
3. Seller expectations – many prefer to wait for higher prices rather than cut their listing.

According to Realtor.com’s housing trends, today’s market is a “study in contrasts.” Buyers are seeing more choices than they’ve had in years, while sellers are often unwilling to settle for less than peak pricing. That tension has opened the door for more homes to enter the rental pool.

What This Means for Renters in Utah

For renters in Salt Lake City and across Utah, this can mean more options—especially when it comes to single-family homes. Families who once struggled to find available houses for lease may now find increased opportunities in desirable neighborhoods.

That said, industry analysts caution against expecting major rent decreases. Instead of annual growth of 4 to 5 percent, rental increases may cool to closer to 1 or 2 percent. For tenants, this provides some relief; for landlords, it means adjusting expectations about how quickly rental income can grow.

The Challenges Facing Accidental Landlords

While renting out a home can be a smart financial move, it comes with challenges many new landlords don’t anticipate. These can include:

• Tenant screening – choosing the right renters to protect the property.
• Maintenance coordination – handling emergency and routine repairs.
• Compliance – understanding Utah’s landlord-tenant laws and regulations.
• Rent collection – ensuring on-time payments and managing finances.

For accidental landlords, the transition from homeowner to rental operator can feel overwhelming without the right systems in place.

Larger Market Trends

This trend isn’t unique to Utah. Across the country, more homes are moving from the “for sale” market into the “for rent” market. Analysts point out that large institutional investors are responding differently by focusing on build-to-rent communities, avoiding direct competition with individual homeowners. At the same time, smaller landlords—especially those new to the role—must balance keeping properties occupied with setting competitive rent prices.

For Utah homeowners, this national shift is especially important. Markets that once saw rapid pandemic-era growth are now cooling, leaving many with properties they’d rather rent than sell at a discount. For a closer look at how these dynamics are playing out nationwide and what it could mean for local owners, check out this in-depth analysis.

How Property Management Can Help

The good news is that homeowners don’t have to tackle this alone. Partnering with a professional property management company can ease the burden by providing:

• Expert tenant placement to minimize risks.
• 24/7 maintenance support to protect the property.
• Compliance guidance to avoid legal issues.
• Market knowledge to set the right rent and maximize returns.

With the right management partner, accidental landlords can transform what feels like a challenge into a rewarding, long-term investment strategy.

Final Thoughts

The rise of accidental landlords is reshaping Utah’s rental market. While many homeowners never planned to rent, this shift is creating new opportunities—both for families looking for housing and for property owners looking to preserve equity while generating income.

At Wolfnest, we help accidental landlords turn uncertainty into confidence. Whether you’ve recently decided to rent your home or want to streamline your rental property operations, our team provides the expertise, tools, and local market knowledge you need to succeed.

If you’re an accidental landlord in Utah, let us show you how professional property management can make all the difference.

FAQs

1. What is an accidental landlord?
An accidental landlord is a homeowner who rents out their property because selling isn’t favorable—often due to high mortgage rates, slow sales, or market conditions.

2. Will more accidental landlords lower rent prices in Utah?
Not necessarily. While supply may increase, experts suggest rental growth will simply slow down to around 1–2 percent annually rather than decline sharply.

3. What challenges do accidental landlords face?
Common hurdles include finding reliable tenants, handling maintenance requests, understanding landlord-tenant laws, and ensuring consistent rent collection.

4. How can property management help accidental landlords?
A property management company like Wolfnest can manage tenant placement, legal compliance, maintenance, and rent collection, making the process smoother and more profitable.

5. Is this trend temporary?
It depends on mortgage rates and housing demand. If rates remain high and sellers hold onto properties, accidental landlords could remain a growing segment of the market for years.

Summarize this content with AI:

Real Estate Investing Resources